Friday, March 18, 2011

Leaving the ECHR? Cameron's Commiission suggests deadlock.

Lobbydog seems to have got there first with the final list of the Commission set to examine the need for a British Bill of Rights, and thus the possibility of the UK opting out of the jurusdiction of the ECHR.

Full membership: Sir Leigh Lewis KCB, Jonathan Fisher QC, Martin Howe QC, Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws QC, Lord Lester of Herne Hill QC, Philippe Sands QC, Anthony Speaight QC, Professor Sir David Edward QC and Dr Michael Pinto-Duschinsky.
Looking at the people on it I wouold say that the result is pre-determined: a Chairman's casting vote.

Sir Leigh Lewis KCB,
Sir Leigh is a career Civil Servant who is a late addition as Chairman. But his opinion will in the end be vital.

Yes to independence/British Bill of Rights

Jonathan Fisher QC,
Fisher is a Conservative lawyer - Pro a British Bill of rights is this pamphlet is anything to go by. And for that matter this evidence to the House seems encouraging.
Martin Howe QC,
Howe is and remains pretty solid on the subject
Dr Michael Pinto-Duschinsky.
Pinto-Duschinsky wrote the Policy Exchange paper demanding a British Bill of Rights, so I would put him in the Yes camp...
Anthony Speaight QC,
Is underdecided if the Society of Conservative Lawyers paper his anything to go by, as he seems to argue that we can (at least in England) avoid the ECHR judgements.

No to Independence/British Bill of Rights
Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws QC,
Helena Kennedy is pretty hard core in favour of the ECHR
Lord Lester of Herne Hill QC,
Strongly Pro ECHR former advisor to Roy Jenkins, Runnymead Trust etc
Philippe Sands QC,
Sands is a member of Matrix Chambers true winners of the HRA and a true believer in the efficacy of International Courts and Law.
Professor Sir David Edward QC
Sir David is a paid up member of the European elite

So as Lobbydog puts it,
Lewis, a former Permanent Secretary at the Department for Work and Pensions with a 'long career in public service', is perfectly positioned to see that this issue remains unresolved well in to 2012.

Looking now at the official anouncement on the MoJ website my heart sinks,
The Commission's full Terms of Reference are:

The Commission will investigate the creation of a UK Bill of Rights that incorporates and builds on all our obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights, ensures that these rights continue to be enshrined in UK law, and protects and extend our liberties.

It will examine the operation and implementation of these obligations, and consider ways to promote a better understanding of the true scope of these obligations and liberties.

It should provide advice to the Government on the ongoing Interlaken process to reform the Strasbourg court ahead of and following the UK's Chairmanship of the Council of Europe.

It should consult, including with the public, judiciary and devolved administrations and legislatures, and aim to report no later than by the end of 2012.
There isn't even the slightest thought that we might leave, not a possibility that we might mitigate the actions of the ECHR, merely that we find a way to tread water or to strengthen the ECHR rights. Please note that it is to build on "All our obligations".

Oh brother.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

The importance of the ECHR

There is a lot on about today's ruling by the ECJ on insurance and gender equality.

Way to go in the week of International Woman's day! Women are henceforward going to be charged equally for something that they need not be.

Brilliant. And anti - rational. But the cargo cult that is the EU can only see in straight lines, not comprehending the truth in the Kant's famous comment about humanity and its actions,

"Out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made"
But that is by-the-by. What I think is extremely important is this statment made by EU Justice Commissioner Viviane Reding (in charge of gender equality at the European Commission). Whilst trumpeting this idiotic decision as a great leap forward for equality (which it may be but a jump backward for women and common sense).
Today's ruling also underlines the power and importance of our Charter of Fundamental Rights. It has the same legal value as our EU Treaties. No EU legislation can be adopted that conflicts with the rights and principles guaranteed by the Charter.

The European Commission issued a 'fundamental rights checklist' last October to make sure that all laws proposed comply with the EU Charter (see IP/10/1348). This checklist ensures that our rules are beyond any reproach. We have also called on the European Parliament and the Council to take a similar fundamental-rights-friendly approach when they add amendments in the EU law-making process. Today's ruling confirms how essential this is.
Now will somebody tell our benighted Government that the EU is not pussyfooting around. They mean what they say, and what they say is that according to the EU, the European Charter, and by extension the rulings of the Court are indeed part and parcel of being a member of the EU.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Lord Carlisle wishes upon a star - or reform of the ECHR

Talking to Civitas today, Lord Carlisle QC has said, in reference to the European Court of Human Rights,

 "I don't think that the European Convention and this whole approach to human rights will endure in this country if we do not tackle the systemic problems we face.

"My first choice would be, at least as part of it, to say 'Let's reform the convention.

"Let's say to all the countries involved, this is not working any better for you than it is for us.'

"We can have a quality-assured system which is returned home to the member countries.
He went on to attack the quality of judges at the ECHR,
"not only have next to no judicial experience, but do not have the experience, even if they have judicial experience, that befits them to be in the superior appellate court".
Interestingly he didn't go on to say what his second choice would be, given that his first choice, the UK goes and gets all 42 countries to agree to reform isn't going to happen in the next millenium. So what will it be Lord Carlisle, just go along with it, shrugging your shoulders saying "Well at least we tried"?

Or will you advocate withdrawal?

Monday, February 21, 2011

Debate and poll on Britain's relationship with the ECHR

This debate has gone live this morning,

The poll questions are,

1) In your opinion, should the European Court of Human Rights be dictating law in Britain?


2) A future Bill of British Rights could block any intervention from the European Court of Human Rights, in principal would you be supportive of this?


3)What's your stance - Should sex offenders have the right to appeal their inclusion on the sex register?

So go on then, get voting.
 
This is my contribution,
Argument against


says Gawain Towler

When was the last time you heard somebody say ‘It’s a free country’ or maybe ‘There should be a law against it’?

Both were ever-present in people’s mouths as I grew up, but now seem jaded, dated, indeed redundant. Why?

Because it isn’t, and their probably is.

And this situation, where an old man can be arrested for fulminating against thugs throwing rocks at ducks, has arisen when we are told that we are living through a Human rights culture. CCTV cameras scan the sky and the roads, children are fingerprinted in school without parental permission, the government’s habit of restricting legal behavior, its hectoring of any who fail to enthusiastically support the new culture of so called tolerance. Something has gone awry in the way we are governed, and the laws which regulate our behaviour.

The last few weeks have seen the first shots in what looks like a long drawn out war between Britain and Europe on this. That these skirmishes are with the European Court of Human Rights rather than the European Union is of little import in the public debate, and within a year or so will be of little import overall as under Article 6 of the Lisbon Treaty will come into force making the European Court art of the institutional structure of the European Union.

The bottom line on the whole issue is who creates the law under which we in the UK are governed by?

UKIP believes and we believe that we are at one with the vast majority of the British people, that we as a nation should be the ones that set the legal parameters by which we are governed.

Ironically of course The European Convention and by extension the European Court of Human Rights were largely British creations. Forged in the vacuum left by the Second World War. To help a shattered continent and the peoples of the nations of Europe have the confidence necessary to build new democratic nations.

The original Convention guarantees uncontroversial things such as the right to a fair trial, not to suffer torture, against slavery, religion, expression, association and so on.

As the Law Lord, Lord Hoffman, former Director Amnesty International has put it recently,

“The brief list of human rights in the 1950 Convention… is, in general terms admirable. Who could object to the government having to respect the rights of its people not to be tortured or inhumanly treated, not to have their privacy invaded, to have a fair trial, or to be free to speak their minds and practice their religions. These freedoms are badge of a civilized society”

What is noticeable is that all of these rights are rights that the lucky British had already. We through didn’t of luck, geography and traditions not succumbed to a dictatorship during the thirties, and therefore did not feel that the Convention was much to do with them Indeed it was felt that what was going on was to bring the continent up to our level.

Scroll forward to 2011 and in a few short months we have seen a series of rulings that rebel against the very gut of the British people. The instruction to give convicted prisoners the vote, the removal of the right of vulnerable victims of crime to give written evidence, the right of appeal for sex offenders to remove themselves from the sex offenders register and most recently the right of the longstanding criminally insane to receive income support and pensions.

And this is just now, with every year the European Court, a Court where judges from such paragons as Russia and Moldova, through its inherent political activism appropriates power over our country.

And here is the nub, as Lord Hoffmann goes on,

“Since the Convention Rights were incorporated into UK law by the Human Rights Act 1998, the UK courts have followed in the wake of Strasbourg, loyally giving effect to its rulings and the principles (where discernable) laid down in its jurisprudence. The result has been that UK judges have reached decisions, sometimes with regret and sometimes with enthusiasm which would have astonished those who agreed to our accession to the Convention in 1950”.

The only way to untangle ourselves from this production line of judgments that fail to chime with the people of the country is to leave the ECHR and to create, or maybe recreate our own system of liberties.

Now as I have suggested neither I nor anybody else is suggesting that many of these liberties we hold should or would be thrown out with our membership of the Convention. Nobody is suggesting that the people of our country would be bereft of protection from the agents of the state.

I do not believe that we can defend our own liberties without leaving the convention, as they are constantly under threat. We must create a system of our own Liberties, perhaps in recasting of the Bill of Rights that since 1689 has guaranteed many of the rights we saw earlier.

It cannot be beyond the wit of this country to come up with a system of rights and liberties far superior than those offered by our continental friends. Rights and Liberties that will set out simply the limits of the state, and the realm in which the individual citizen may continue in his or her life unmolested by its agents.

 

Blogger news

Blogroll

About