Ronny Patz over at Polscieu has taken issue with my previous post about the gulf between the public and the publically funded as evidenced by the report on the consultation over new tobacco restrictions being proposed by the European Commision. Here is my ripost.
Whilst it is undoubtedly true that 57% of the private citizen came from a couple of lobbying campaigns, and of that 30,000 came from the Italian tobacconists (got to admire their pluck though, don't you think, wish ours were as pro-active) that doesn't actually negate my point at all.
If you recall that on top of the full contributions there was a further 18,650 signatures on petitions, those signatures, though collected by institutions such as retailers etc count as bona fide citizens? Or do we write off petitions entirely (which would screw up the citizen's initiative for a start).
In addition, the Commission also received 10 petitions from citizens, retailers, traders, wholesalers, gas station owners and trade unions. In total these petitions counted for around 18 650 signatures. Four of the petitions collected more than 1000 signatures each.
If you take out the duplicates spotted by the Commission we are left with the tiny figure of 36,325 individual contributions. Including my own.
Anyhow, taking out all the form and Italian tobacconist responses (though I would suggest that they have a legitimate interest and should be counted in some way) we are left with 3396 organisational responses (Govt, NGO, Industry etc) and 36,325.
So individual citizen responses outnumber official responses by a factor of 1:10.
An interesting comment in the report is the difference between the responses and the Eurobarometer survey with the Commission pointing out that the Eurobarometer survey is far more in line with the Governmental/NGO position than the balance of this report.
To which my rejoinder would be twofold.
1) Well Eurobarometer always tells the Commission what it wants to hear. I recall that the Eurobarometer from the Netherlands informing us a week before the No vote in the Constitution referendum that a significant (65% if I remember rightly) majority of the Dutch were in favour of the Constitution. I have never seen Eurobarometer report that doesn't support the chosen policy prescription of the Commission.. Have you?
2) This suggests that the vast majority of people really don't care either way, but of those that do care, would prefer less legislation.
As far as I can work out talking to people and conducting my own deeply unscientific research on the issue you can split the population into three bands on the smoking issue, vis-a-vis restrictions.
There is a vocal minority that opposes, strongly, bans (about 20% mostly smokers and freedom enthusiasts)
There is a very vocal minority (that have captured the funds and the political class about 5%) who hate smoking and would ban it entirely but in the meantime make do with the sort of stuff proposed by this legislation because they now they would cause revolt.
And then there is the vast majority of generally non smokers who don't particularly like smoking but really don't care, and are happy for people to smoke if they want to. (about 75%)
Going back to your post however, the facts about the survey you highlight are correct, but I don't think change my argument one iota.
The political elite and the publicly funded (Para) -NGO's like ASH and the Smoke Free Partnership, allied with big Pharma who can make a mint out of smoking cessation products are on one side of this argument, and the broad mass of the people are actively opposed to them or at worst indifferent.
Home » All posts
Friday, July 29, 2011
Right back at you Ronny... :-)
Citizen versus NGOs
A very revealing report has been published by the European Commission. In it we see, highlighted the wide divide between the powers that be, the hangers on and the public citizen.
It is an interim report into the latest plans to dehumanise the smoker, or otherwise known as,
Report on the public consultation on the possible revision of the Tobacco Products Directive (2001/37/EC)The question is shall we make the laws against smoking in public more onerous, shall we create more restrictions on tobacco products, shall we make health warnings bigger, shall we point out that smokers eat babies and are often seen strangling fluffy kittens etc etc etc.
Here are a small collection of the responses
From
Governmental Representatives
A significant majority of Member States who submitted contributions to the public consultation were either in favour of extending the scope of the Directive or did not refer to the question in a detailed manner.or
The majority of Member States were in favour of banning all types of smokeless tobacco products, which was also the position of the two EFTA countries responding to the consultation.or
While most Member States were in favour of all proposed policy options for improving consumer information, plain packaging proved to be the most controversial. Almost half of respondents supported the introduction of plain packaging alongside the other recommended changes, but several indicated that the solutions to these problems should be more carefully analysed. A small number of Member States were in favour of maintaining the existing regulations, noting a strong reservation against plain packaging.or
Member States were in favour of establishing a common compulsory reporting format for communicating ingredients information.or
Almost all Member States supported some form of increased tobacco control across the range of options, though the specific breakdown of options was quite varied. Most Member States supported a ban on internet sales or a ban on vending machines.Non-Governmental Organisations
Now there are two forms of NGOs in this list, those funded by Governments, and those supporting smokers rights which are not. I shall concentrate on the publicly funded Para Governmental organisations - here called 'Public Health Organisations'
Public health organisations universally supported regulating tobacco and nicotine products, on the grounds of the potential health dangers of these products. Many argued for the strict limitation of novel forms of nicotine delivery systems, whereby these nicotine systems should only be sold as smoking cessation aids, subject to the regulatory framework on pharmaceutical products. They also argued for the inclusion of herbal cigarettes into this framework, citing that the most harm from these products has to do with the combustion and inhalation of smoke, which is identical to cigarette usage.or
Public health organisations emphatically maintained the ‘high priority’ status of the current ban on snus within the EU. According to these respondents, there is no legitimate reason to introduce a dangerous product onto the market, because it is impossible to predict how snus would be perceived or used in other countries.or
Arguments were presented to increase the size of the pictorial warnings to 80% of the pack, to regularly rotate warning messages to maintain the ‘freshness’ of each statement, and to include information on the packaging about a 'quit line' to help stop smoking.or,
Additionally, public health organisations opted for plain packaging on the grounds that branding tactics used today can give the consumer a false sense that one pack may be safer than another.
Almost all respondents pushed for the need to establish a common compulsory reporting format and to introduce fees and sanctions to cover the costs of data collection and analysis work on ingredients.or
Public health organisations were universally in favour of banning all possible categories in this question. Banning sales of tobacco via the internet was argued to be a logical extension of the ban on cross-border advertising and promotion of tobacco products within the EU.You get the idea, bans, restrictions, more legislation, harsher controls and so on from both Governments and their paid paramilitaries.
Banning vending machine access was justified by public health organisations on the grounds that most Member States already have bans or restrictions in place, which have been shown to reduce youth smoking rates. Finally, restricting display and promotion of tobacco products at the point of sale was claimed to be justified because it is or will soon be mandatory in some Member States. Proponents argued that restricting display of tobacco products also helps limit youth smoking and could help deter tobacco purchases by adults.
Now lets see what the citizen responses were, could they differ from those that govern them. Could they disagree with those that know so much more than them... Maybe
Citizens
A significant majority of respondents were against extending the scope of the Directive. While many presented that the problem definition was incorrect, vague, or unclear, the group as a whole demanded more scientific inquiry about the relative safety of novel forms of tobacco and other nicotine products. These respondents also argued about the consumer's freedom of choice, so long as they are properly informed with the risks involved, and they criticised the tendency to over-regulate and prohibit products in this area.or
A vast majority of respondents not only disagreed with the problem definition but were in favour of lifting the ban on snus. With the problem definition, several respondents were concerned that the Commission’s approach was too simplistic and overstated – referring to the complex nature and health effects of a diverse smokeless tobacco products market. Those in favour of lifting the ban on snus argued that scientific evidence showed that smokeless products were much healthier alternatives to tobacco smoking. Several respondents pushed for smokeless tobacco products to be priced cheaper than combustible products, in order to reduce the demand for cigarettes. Others were concerned about their freedom of choice as consumers, with several arguing that those over 18 years old should be free to decide for themselves. Still others felt that the EU already had too many regulations in place to begin creating more.or
Largely in favour of maintaining the status quo, most respondents suggested that little, if any, scientific evidence exists to show that many of these options are effective ways to reduce smoking rates, or reduce youth uptake. They also argued that the EU did not need to establish more restrictions; smokers were already facing too much regulation to use a product they are legally entitled to consume. Education, they suggest, should not only be limited to the tobacco packaging, but should also be increased in schools and public campaigns. Finally, some respondents were worried that the use of plain packaging not only prevented free competition between manufacturers, but also increased the likelihood of counterfeit products entering the market.or
Respondents were generally in favour of establishing a common compulsory reporting format, insomuch as the format was based on appropriate scientific criteria, and not based on concepts such as attractiveness. They, like many of the organisations and governments above, argued that the current ingredients reporting situation is fragmented, making it difficult for authorities to compare and analyse ingredients data. Manufacturers and importers, they reasoned, should be subject to the same reporting standards. Other respondents furthered this point by demanding that consumers have a right to know what is inside the products they use....or
However, on the whole, not all respondents were in favour of changes to the status quo. Many advocated no restrictions, no further bans, and no changes, resulting in more freedom for tobacco products and their users. Others utilised this section to insert more general commentary on the EU’s role in standardising product regulation.
A significant majority of respondents disagreed with the regulation of ingredients at the EU level. The majority of respondents referred to the lack of scientific evidence for such regulation on reducing tobacco consumption or youth uptake. Additionally, they criticised the term 'attractiveness' as a justification for the EU to arbitrarily decide which ingredients will be allowed and which not. The other arguments referred to a consumer's freedom of choice and a generally critical response to the EU's tendency to over-regulate.or
A significant majority of respondents opposed limiting access to tobacco products. The most commonly discussed issue was the display ban, where citizen arguments were similar to those used by industry representatives. The limitation of the legitimate use of the trademarks and branding displays, the lack of the possibility for customers to be fully informed about the accessibility, the price and characteristic of products and potential increase of the illicit trade were the most often used arguments. Some of the responses referred to the lack of scientific evidence that bans on the point of sale display of tobacco would impact smoking behaviour.This argument also referred to a lack of research regarding both vending machines and internet sales. The significant majority of respondents perceived these restrictions as an excessive intervention in a consumer's right to decide. Rather, these respondents opted for more effective controls, such as age verification, in these channels of tobacco products.Here we see it writ large. Those with cash and power want increasing control, those without it don't. Those with cash and power want action before evidence, those without want to see evidence before action. Those with power and cash want legislation restrictions and bans, those without complain that there are too many controls already.
Now when the recommendations arrive in a few months, who so we think the EU will listen to?
Thursday, July 28, 2011
The tasty tipping point
When things change they change fast, is the message of the famous book by Malcolm Gladwell . He points out that big events are often caused small things.
So I bring to you a small thing that could have the capcity to presage a big event. In this local difficulty we can see the great mchines of France and German y's differing cultures, and the problems that always occur when law and systems are homogenised,
French Agriculture Minister Bruno Le Maire has threatened to boycott this year's Anuga trade show after a decision to stop foie gras producers from exhibiting at the event.
The move has angered French producers and Le Maire has written to his German counterpart Ilse Aigner and said he may not attend the show's opening ceremony in Cologne in October.
"Products that respect current EU legislation should all have access," Le Maire said. Most retail foie gras sales occur towards the end of the year, making Anuga the last opportunity to secure business. In China, foie gras sales are soaring and French producer Delpeyrat has already set up a production unit in the country.
Foie gras was not re-entered in the catalogue listings for Anuga 2011 after animal welfare groups caused security issues at the last event in 2009.
"We had some problems in 2009 and we have been talking to French producers for years about excluding it from Anuga," a spokesperson for the event told just-food. "We didn't expect diplomatic reactions."
France is the largest producer of foie gras and has responded the most vigorously to the ban, although the ruling applies equally to Belgian, Spanish, Bulgarian and Hungarian producers.
The German minister is not expected to overturn the show's decision. The presence of foie gras had already been a contentious issue among exhibitors, the Anuga spokesperson added.
Getting between a Frenchman and his foodstuffs is always a very dangerous game.
Wednesday, July 27, 2011
Did Ed fib about his love of Boycott?
Last year Ed made some interesting claims about his love of Geoff Boycott, describing the irascible old Yorkshireman as having the 'Charisma of Imperfection'.
But looking at the claims I fear the imperfection must be in the memory of Ed. It looks to me as if the chap was having his Bahamas moment,
in conversation with Des O'Connor in 1996 that Tony Blair told a yarn about running away from school and smuggling himself aboard a flight to the Bahamas at Newcastle Airport - an anecdote subsequently greeted with blank amazement by Mr Blair's father and the authorities at Newcastle Airport, which has never had a direct flight to the Bahamas.Ed claims to have seen Boycott's 100th century, which was scored at Headingly in August 1977 in an interview with James Forsyth in the Spectator
Given that Ed was 7 ½ at the time I wonder who took him? After all he was a primary schoolboy at the time. I just cannot see his father, the old Polish, Marxist, emigre intellectual trekking up the M1 on the demands of the youthful Ed to watch a day's cricket in Leeds. It just stretches the envelope of believability. His second claim is equally dubious. He can claim that he "bunked off school" to see Boycott at Lords as that test was on the 2-7 of July in 1981. But, but, you see when Forsyth reprised the tale in a later article he added details, no doubt referring back to his recording of the interview,
"he celebrated the end of his GCSEs by going to watch Boycott’s final first-class innings at Lord’s."Well it was certainly Boycott's final Test match at Lords but he was playing first class cricket there until 1986, but we can forgive the adoring fan Ed that mistake, but...
I know that Ed was a bright boy, but was he really celebrating his GCSE's when he was 11 ½? In his second term at Haverlock Comprehensive? No.
The whole 'I love cricket and Boycott' schtik stinks from start to finish, capped off by his rejection of an invitation to Test Match Special recently. I think that he has been inventing his past. Boycott is still very popular in his old fastness of South Yorkshire. And Milliband desperately needs working class credibility in Doncaster.
Update
As pointed out by Jim in the comments and as I recognised here last night I suspect I might be entirely unfair about this. Damn that I don't have a Wisden.
My bad
Monday, July 25, 2011
A European Patriotism
John Bruton is a prime example of the European Elite. As a former Taoiseach and EU Ambasador to Washington he encapsulates the European capture of the national political classes.
As Brussels dithered last week he spoke to the Google Global Leaders forum in Dublin.
In it he talked about the crisis as he and the elite see it, a problem of the way in which people, even politicians think,
How to solve this problem? How indeed? By the creation of something new,
The European Union will only survive the dramatic changes that the twenty first century will bring if the citizens of all EU states develop a common sense of European patriotism, alongside their national patriotisms.Oh really and how will that happen?
European patriotism, like national patriotism, is not something that will arise spontaneously. It has to be fostered by the use of symbols, and appeals to people’s emotions, by political leaders who make a conscious decision to do so.National patriotism doesn't arise spontaneously? No I suppose over the passage of centuries they have been built and created, but so slowly and so incrementally as to have the appearence of spontaneity. What the EU is trying to do is create a patriotism at warp drive. Which of course will have the opposite effect than that which they desire.
His prescription of a directly elected European President is just not going to work. Because no public figure (baring the odd pop star) has public recognition across the EU.
As Jody Corcoran has said in the Sunday Independent (IRE) about the background to this speech,
Motivated by a combination of immediate greed and a desire to maintain a form of social cohesion, the risk is that these forces will fail to see the bigger picture: that Ireland, like Greece, will end up a vassal state.So the omens are not good.
Add to that the influence being brought to bear by the grandees of Fine Gael, such as John Bruton, Peter Sutherland, even Pat Cox, the man most recently described as an "ultra-europhile".
Many prominent Europeans have privately welcomed the eurozone catastrophe, labelling it a "beneficial crisis": never waste a good recession, they say.
The issue is relatively simple, though: on that red-eye to Beijing, how will you want your great grandchildren to reply: "I am from Europe" or "I am from Ireland"?
Greece was finally forced to surrender last week; others may quickly follow. The choice is clear: nothing less than the sovereignty of the State is now at stake.
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Orwelian Titles in Local Government
Meet Jane Beck,
Happy little bunny isn't she? She earns over £50,000 as an official at Great Yarmouth Borough Council. Her title is magnificent.
There she is, Director of Well-Being Services
All rather cuddly don't you think. Must involve apple pies and kittens in baskets. Well, errr.. no.
Housing NeedsNot a puppy to be seen.
Benefits, Cust. Services & Bereav'ment
Revenues & Debt Management
Private Sector H'sing
Construction Services
Get real Yarmouth
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
If Sir Paul Stephenson is referring to Llewellyn, then Ed is toast
In the hearing just now Sir Paul Stevenson has said that a "Senior official" at Number 10 advised not telling Cameron about Neil Wallis's job with the Met.
If that senior official is Ed Llewellyn then his career is over.

